By Pexcel John Bacon, Reporter
GOVERNMENT agencies that repeatedly fail to address audit findings should face tighter budget scrutiny and possible restrictions on funding for new projects, political analysts said.
Dennis C. Coronacion, chairman of the University of Santo Tomas Political Science Department, proposed linking agencies’ compliance with Commission on Audit (CoA) recommendations to eligibility for higher budgets.
The Department of Budget and Management and Congress should enforce a “no compliance, no expansion” rule during annual budget hearings, requiring agencies to address previous audit findings before receiving additional funding for projects, he said.
Agencies with unimplemented CoA recommendations, unliquidated cash advances, or low budget use should face stricter scrutiny or conditional freezes on project funds until they resolve outstanding deficiencies.
“This way, agencies with high rates of unimplemented CoA recommendations, unliquidated cash advances or low absorptive capacity should face stricter scrutiny or conditional freezes on new project funds until prior audit flags are resolved,” Mr. Coronacion said in a Facebook Messenger chat.
Recurring findings suggest agencies treat internal controls as paperwork requirements rather than safeguards against the misuse or inefficient management of public funds, he pointed out. “When the same audit flags appear year after year, it shows that internal controls are being treated merely as a paperwork exercise rather than a real safeguard for public funds.”
Mr. Coronacion said limited administrative capacity, weak accountability mechanisms and the lack of swift consequences contribute to recurring deficiencies.
Ederson DT. Tapia, a political science professor at the University of Makati, said repeated audit findings reflect weaknesses in how agencies plan, manage and spend public funds.
“We have an extensive system of budgeting, procurement, accounting and auditing, but having these mechanisms in place does not necessarily mean that agencies are able to make them work as intended,” he said via Facebook Messenger.
Unused appropriations and delayed projects could postpone government assistance and services for intended beneficiaries, he said.
“We tend to measure government spending in terms of how much has been allocated or disbursed, when the more important question is what the public actually received from that expenditure,” he said.
Some agencies lack the personnel, technical expertise and administrative systems needed to meet complex financial management and procurement requirements, Mr. Tapia said.
However, he cautioned against attributing every audit deficiency to limited capacity, particularly when agencies repeatedly receive the same findings after being told how to correct them. Agency leaders must ensure that audit recommendations lead to administrative changes, he said.
Mr. Tapia also warned against treating every CoA finding as evidence of corruption, saying an audit observation alone does not establish wrongdoing.
Repeated noncompliance without adequate justification, however, raises accountability concerns, particularly when agencies fail to correct previously identified deficiencies.
“If an agency has been informed of a deficiency and continues to encounter the same problem without adequate justification, then accountability must also concern the failure to correct what is already known to be wrong,” he said.
Mr. Tapia called for deadlines to implement audit recommendations, regular monitoring and explanations for unresolved findings.
He said agencies also need stronger administrative capacity and that sanctions should apply when negligence or disregard of responsibilities causes repeated violations, subject to due process.
“Ultimately, we should not be satisfied simply because government funds have been accounted for,” he said. “We must also establish whether those funds were used properly and whether they produced the services and outcomes for which they were appropriated.”