(Second of two parts)
The Philippines already knows how to recycle used lead-acid batteries safely. Formal recycling facilities exist, and regulations are in place to manage hazardous waste. Yet not every used battery makes its way into these systems. The challenge, then, is making sure that more batteries actually reach the facilities equipped to recycle them safely.
A battery’s journey does not end when it dies. After its useful life, much of the lead it contains can be recovered, either through relatively more costly formal recycling methods or through less costly but hazardous informal means. Because informal recyclers face lower costs, they can offer competitive prices for used lead-acid batteries while still earning a return from the value of the recovered lead. This creates an incentive for used batteries to flow into informal channels rather than formal recycling. When too many batteries fall outside the formal system, the consequences can extend beyond lost materials. Unsafe dismantling and recycling can release lead into the environment, creating risks for workers and nearby communities, particularly children.
This is why safe battery recycling is not only a matter of technology. It is also a matter of stewardship. Producers are responsible for the quality and safety of the products they put on the market. But a product’s impact does not necessarily end with the person who buys it. Batteries can impose costs on society and the environment long after they have been sold, particularly when they reach the end of their useful lives. When this happens, public policy has a role to play in ensuring that these costs are properly addressed.
In other words, the responsibility of battery stewardship should extend beyond the point of sale. Companies that place batteries on the market would also have a role in ensuring that those batteries are collected when they reach the end of their useful lives and sent to facilities that can process them safely. This is the basic idea behind Extended Producer Responsibility, or EPR.
Under an EPR scheme, producers and importers are given responsibility for supporting the collection and environmentally sound processing of used batteries. This does not mean that producers and importers must physically collect every battery themselves. Rather, EPR can create a framework in which they help finance, organize, or otherwise support the systems needed to bring used batteries back into formal recycling channels.
Building a stronger collection and recycling system is not costless. Collection networks have to be organized, batteries have to be transported, recyclers have to meet environmental and safety standards, and producers and importers have to comply with the requirements of the EPR scheme. Our analysis estimates these incremental costs at approximately P910 million annually. These are real costs that any EPR scheme must take into account. But the benefits of doing so are far greater.
Under current conditions, an estimated 60% of used lead-acid batteries are recycled through formal channels. Under the EPR scenario, effective formal recycling could increase to approximately 85.5%, based on a 90% collection target and an assumed compliance rate of 95%.
That increase matters because each battery redirected from unsafe recycling is an opportunity to reduce lead exposure. By reducing the amount of lead released into the environment, higher rates of formal recycling can reduce children’s exposure to lead and, in turn, the risk of cognitive harm associated with that exposure.
The economic consequences of that protection are significant. For children born in 2026, the analysis estimates approximately P31.2 billion in lifetime productivity losses associated with cognitive impairment from lead exposure under current recycling conditions. Under the modeled EPR scenario, these losses fall to approximately P11.3 billion, representing an estimated P19.8 billion in avoided productivity losses.
To put things in perspective, the P19.8 billion estimate is roughly equivalent to the 2026 appropriation of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) Office of the Secretary. Yet the significance of the estimate goes beyond the number itself. These gains come from protecting something that is difficult to see on a balance sheet but enormously valuable to the country: children’s ability to learn, develop, and contribute productively as adults.
Compared with the estimated P910 million in additional annual costs of formalization, this suggests that every additional peso spent could be associated with more than P21 in lifetime productivity gains for a single birth cohort.
And the P19.8 billion estimate does not capture every potential benefit. The analysis focuses specifically on productivity gains associated with improvements in cognitive outcomes. It does not include potential reductions in healthcare costs, improvements in environmental quality, or broader social benefits. The full value of preventing lead exposure could therefore be greater.
EPR is not a silver bullet. A successful system still depends on effective regulation, compliance, collection infrastructure, formal recycling capacity, and participation from consumers and other actors throughout the battery’s life cycle. EPR is a way of strengthening the connections between these pieces, giving producers and importers a defined role in helping ensure that used batteries do not fall out of the system.
This brings us back to where we began: The country is already investing in its children through education, nutrition, healthcare, and social protection. Protecting those investments also means preventing environmental risks that can erode their benefits.
Every battery that reaches a formal recycler is one less opportunity for preventable lead exposure. Better battery stewardship can therefore do more than recover valuable materials. It can protect workers and communities, reduce environmental contamination, and preserve the human capital that the country is already working so hard to build.
The battery may stop working when it is replaced. Our responsibility for what happens next does not.
Gage Andal is a researcher at Action for Economic Reforms.