BEREA ― The Browns once again have relied heavily on rookies in some key positions. Once again, those rookies appear to be up to the task of playing in the NFL.

The 2026 rookie class for the Browns, coupled with the 2025 class that drew rave reviews, are forming a foundation upon which they can build a playoff contender. That reality may already be here with Cleveland 6-4 and No. 7 in the AFC playoff race as it reaches its bye week.

Those initial 10 games are also a perfect opportunity to go back and assess exactly where the rookies who have spent time on the 53-man roster are in their development. It may be a bit unfair to judge someone 10 games into his first NFL season, but consider it a snapshot of a moment in their growth.

Subscribe to Browns Insider newsletter

We’ll go in alphabetical order. That means we’re going to start with maybe one of the more surprising rookie contributors.

Austin Barber, right guard, third-round pick

There were plenty who didn’t even know who Barber was when the Browns traded back into the third round to select the former University of Florida offensive tackle. However, he quickly became known within the organization, even if there were questions about where his ultimate position was going to be on the line. A natural left tackle coming out of college, Barber was flipped to the right side with fellow rookie Spencer Fano and fourth-year pro Dawand Jones working there. Then, in mid-August, Barber was shifted inside to right guard, a position he had never played in an actual game, and almost instantly took to it like he’d played it his entire life. He’s started all 10 games there. Although Barber hasn’t been perfect, he’s certainly performed well enough at an unnatural position that there’s a lot of intrigue over what his ceiling could become.

Grade: B+

Denzel Boston, wide receiver, second-round pick

The mistake other teams made in passing on Boston provided the second part of the Browns’ rookie wide receiver draft haul. That haul, with first-round pick KC Concepcion included, has been franchise-altering. Boston immediately arrived in Cleveland looking like a player other teams had woefully undervalued. The size was there, and so were the hands. What Boston has since shown is the big-play ability, which other teams apparently underestimated because he’s such a fluid glider when he runs. That big-play ability may have saved the season with Boston’s touchdown catch against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in Week 2. Boston’s 523 receiving yards are tops for all rookies, and his 33 receptions are in the top five for all rookies. The big thing coming back from the bye is getting Boston healthy from a toe injury that hampered him right before the break, even though he played through the pain.

Grade: A

Parker Brailsford, center, fifth-round pick

Injuries hampered Brailsford throughout training camp. That prevented him from making any progress toward finding a way to get on the field, as he’s been inactive for all but one game this season. That makes it hard to actually grade on-field performance, but grade we must.

Grade: C

KC Concepcion, wide receiver, first-round pick

The other half of the best rookie wide receiving duo in the NFL this season. Concepcion has been everything that was advertised about him. Browns coach Todd Monken has absolutely utilized him in much the same way he used Zay Flowers with the Baltimore Ravens. Concepcion has been all over the formation, and hurt defenses in multiple ways. The previous two weeks finally allowed him to show the true big-play pass-catching ability, with a 64-yard touchdown catch against the New Orleans Saints, and rushing ability, with an end-around counter touchdown run against the Houston Texans. On a team full of guys who have played through the pain, Concepcion also may be one of the toughest of them all. He shook off a nasty hit in Week 5 by the New York Jets’ Minkah Fitzpatrick to return the very next week, and on multiple other occasions barely missed plays because of what looked in the moment like serious injuries. Concepcion’s 40 catches are the most for any rookie, and his 458 receiving yards are up there as well.

Grade: A

Spencer Fano, left tackle, first-round pick

Fano had roughly 12 games of experience at left tackle when he arrived with the Browns. That came all the way back as a freshman at the University of Utah. However, the Browns never backed down from their belief Fano was going to be their left tackle, and Fano never backed down from the challenge of learning the position. After spending the offense and first part of training camp alternating with Jones, he finally grabbed the job for himself with a strong Saturday training camp practice that featured him and Jared Verse in a Royal Rumble match, and then more than hold his own between the whistles against Verse at the line of scrimmage. Fano has had moments when the rookie learning a somewhat-new position has looked just like that, a rookie learning a somewhat-new position. However, he’s also had a number of games in which you see what he can grow into over time. The reality of it is that expecting every first-round tackle to be Joe Thomas is a fool’s errand. Fano may never be that, but he certainly has a chance to be a solid 10-plus-year starter at the position.

Grade: B+

Taylen Green, quarterback, sixth-round pick

Green getting onto the field as a rookie always seemed like a very long shot. He barely got training camp reps until late in the week of a Buffalo Bills joint practice and preseason game. Green was always viewed as a long-term development project, especially considering his 6-foot-6, 230-pound frame. There was some talk about potentially using Green in some designed packages way back at the beginning of the season, but that talk has been shut down by the fact he’s been inactive the entire season. He did spend seven games as the emergency No. 3 quarterback while Dillon Gabriel was on injured reserve, but now is No. 4 with Gabriel back. Although others who have spent most of their rookie seasons inactive have been given grades, it’s really hard to do here considering the position and the lack of legitimate opportunity.

Grade: Incomplete

Justin Jefferson, linebacker, fifth-round pick

Jefferson seemed like a potential special-teams star for the Browns when you watched him in the offseason and training camp. Instead, the Browns seemed to have decided to go in a different direction. Jefferson’s only been active twice, not the kind of start to a career one wants.

Grade: C

Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, safety, second-round pick

This is a player who you should fully expect to receive more snaps over the final seven games than he’s already received over the first 10. McNeil-Warren’s rookie season started out with him mostly watching in the offseason program because of a nagging injury. However, he clearly paid attention in the meeting room and while he was sidelined, because when he’s been on the field he’s looked like he’s belonged. The Browns played him a lot as the No. 3 safety in their three-safety looks, including three games he started because of that coverage scheme. However, he started in place of Ronnie Hickman in Week 10 because Hickman was out with a concussion. No one is suggesting Hickman be Wally Pipp-ed in place of the rookie. However, could the Browns do with McNeil-Warren what they did with Hickman when he was backing up Juan Thornhill, which is increase the number of snaps in the two-safety looks by alternating series? Maybe. McNeil-Warren has certainly earned the reps.

Grade: B

Buy Cleveland Browns tickets

Carsen Ryan, tight end, seventh-round pick

Ryan has yo-yoed between the active roster and the practice squad, depending on what the Browns have needed to do to maintain their roster at 53. Even when he’s been on the practice squad, though, he’s been a gameday elevation twice because of a need on special teams. Otherwise, in terms of pure tight end play, Ryan has not provided much at all.

Grade: C

Chris Easterling can be reached at ceasterling@thebeaconjournal.com. Read more about the Browns at www.beaconjournal.com/sports/browns. Follow him on X at @ceasterlingABJ. Sign up for Browns Insider newsletter at https://profile.beaconjournal.com/newsletters/browns-insider/

This article originally appeared on Akron Beacon Journal: How have Browns' 2026 rookies graded out? Here's a look at bye week

Our editors independently choose our recommendations. Some content is produced with paid support from a third party, however our editorial decisions remain independent. If you buy through our links, the USA TODAY Network may earn a commission. Prices and availability may change.