Somebody make the playoff pitch for Indiana without using the words “defending national champions” or “Fernando Mendoza.”

This team is not that team.

What happened last year shouldn’t matter.

That team was a wrecking crew, led by an elite quarterback. That team trounced most opponents.

This team finds itself in one-score tussles most weekends. Play with fire as often as the Hoosiers do, and you’ll get burned. Indiana is fortunate to have only been burned twice.

Opinion: Bill Belichick is 'bad, bad.' UNC football must consider a $10 million decision

Brawl of the Wild: A day with the greatest rivalry in FCS football

The 2025 Hoosiers had a Heismandoza.

These Hoosiers possess quarterback warts. They’ll go into the regular-season finale against Purdue without a clearly defined starter.

Both metrics and the eye test cast doubt about Indiana’s playoff resume, after its 27-24 overtime loss to Washington.

"We couldn't close it out," Curt Cignetti said. "... Too many missed opportunities."

Indiana missed the opportunity to leave no doubt about its playoff status.

Putting last year aside, let’s consider Indiana’s credentials.

The Hoosiers now have a pair of losses to 7-4 teams. That makes for a tough start to this debate.

What’s Indiana’s best win? That’d be a 27-13 triumph over Southern Cal. OK, but didn’t Oregon also beat USC by 14 points, and doesn’t Oregon also possess a much stronger strength of schedule than Indiana?

OK, but you say two-loss Indiana’s got a better record than three-loss Oregon.

So, you want to argue record?

In that case, UCLA, Wake Forest and Texas Tech block Indiana’s playoff runway.

In a head-to-head comparison with bubble-residing Brigham Young, Indiana’s case unravels. The two teams have identical records, and Indiana has no wins on par with BYU’s triumph over Notre Dame.

Indiana can’t help its resume much next week. Purdue stinks.

Look purely at this team’s credentials, and forget last season, and Indiana’s resume starts to look a lot like Iowa’s.

Oh, and by the way, Iowa is not making this playoff without receiving a bit of help during rivalry week.

But, here’s where it gets interesting: Humans on a committee award the seven at-large bids, and those humans must remember how good Indiana looked last year. That could persuade them to give Indiana the benefit of the doubt over, say, a Texas Tech team that hasn’t beaten anyone of consequence and got crushed in the playoff last year.

What happened last season shouldn’t matter, but try telling that to selectors who remember the 2025 Hoosiers went undefeated.

Indiana’s “defending national champions” status and its first-of-its-kind 16-0 record in the annals are the best arguments going for these Hoosiers in this bubble conversation.

This committee shouldn’t take that into consideration, but human nature says they won’t be able to forget that last year happened.

Indiana’s playoff hopes are pinned to the committee giving this team the benefit of the doubt, because of what the 2025 Hoosiers achieved.

CFP rankings predictions, Playoff bracket projections

Here’s one guess for how the next CFP rankings will take shape:

  1. Georgia (10-1): The SEC Championship means more to Kirby Smart than any other active coach. So, it’s fitting that the 35th and final installment of the conference’s title game will feature Georgia.
  2. Utah (11-0): The Utes outlasted UCLA to become college football’s final undefeated team. They lack the strength of schedule to be ranked No. 1, but No. 2 opposite Georgia would be a fine spot in the bracket.
  3. Texas (9-2): Put the Alabama-Tennessee debate on hold for a moment, and consider the Alabama-Texas debate. The committee cannot justify putting Alabama ahead of Texas. The Tide lack the resume to support it.
  4. Alabama (9-2): The Tide’s credentials slip every time Kentucky, LSU and South Carolina lose, and every time Tennessee wins, but the committee remains infatuated with Alabama, as if they forgot what happened on The Third Saturday in October. Expect the committee to be giddy over Alabama’s 47-0 rout of an FCS opponent.
  5. Notre Dame (10-1): The Irish started slowly against SMU, but on another chaotic weekend across the country, Notre Dame came out unscathed. The Irish’s schedule strength keeps it out of a first-round bye slot.
  6. Miami (10-1): The Hurricanes survived another ACC game without Malachi Toney. With woeful Boston College on deck, they can live without Toney for another week. But, they badly need him back for the postseason.
  7. Tennessee (9-2): The Vols’ defense squeezed the guts out of another SEC opponent. Unfortunately for Tennessee, this committee likes beauty pageant performances more than stalwart defense. The committee should ask itself, though: If Alabama is so good, how come Tennessee smashed the Tide?
  8. UCLA (10-1): The Bruins’ playoff hopes will be on the line against Southern Cal. Quarterback Ty Dieffenbach is dealing with an injury suffered in overtime of the loss to Michigan. UCLA’s Cinderella story is on life support.
  9. Wake Forest (10-1): The more teams collapse around Wake Forest, the more impressive the Demon Deacons’ eight-game win streak looks, even if the ACC stinks.
  10. BYU (9-2): People often question whether playing a quality opponent in the non-conference schedule is worth the risk. BYU is the case for why it can be. The Cougars’ resume is held together by that win against Notre Dame. Without it, BYU would not have a playoff resume.
  11. Indiana (9-2): The committee can keep the defending national champions in the bracket this week without committing to awarding Indiana a bid. If Oregon keeps winning, the Ducks will become Big Ten champions, and they could snatch this spot away from Indiana.
  12. Texas Tech (10-1): Putting the Red Raiders here would give the committee options. If the Red Raiders win the Big 12, they'd steal a bid. If they don’t win the Big 12, well, they were never in the bracket to begin with, right?

∎ Group of Six top team: Boise State (9-2). The committee cannot fall into the Liberty trap. Although Boise State just lost to San Diego State, the Broncos will retain the best G6 resume so long as they beat Colorado State and then win the Pac-12 Championship.

∎ On the playoff’s doorstep: Oregon (8-3), Iowa (9-2).

Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's senior national college football columnist. Listen to his podcast, "College Football Unfiltered."Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Indiana football lacks CFP credentials, unless last year suddenly counts