Indiana football coach Curt Cignetti's decision to replace his field goal kicker didn't work out in a 27-24 overtime loss to Washington.
The No. 5 Hoosiers (9-2, 6-2 Big Ten) benched Nico Radicic in favor of kickoff specialist Paddy McAteer, but he missed a 37-yard field goal attempt in overtime that would have extended the game. The personnel change came after Radicic had a 46-yard attempt blocked in the third quarter.
"We missed too many field goals this year," Cignetti said. "And the other guy had made them. That was the plan going in. We gave him an opportunity and he missed a field goal."
Doyel: IU loses to Washington? Bad. CFP selection committee doesn’t seem to like Hoosiers? Worse
It continued a nightmare season for Radicic, who went 28 of 30 from 2024-25 and earned Big Ten Kicker of the Year honors in 2025.
McAteer hasn't been perfect this season — he came into the game 2 of 4 on field goal attempts — but made an impression on the staff by setting a program record with a 60-yard field goal in a high pressure situation against Minnesota.
He connected on a 34-yarder to give Indiana a 17-14 lead with 6:08 to go in the third quarter.
Overreactions: Indiana football's overtime loss at Washington makes CFP a long shot
While Cignetti briefly deliberated over who should get the kick in overtime, he opted to stick with McAteer with IU needing a field goal to extend the game.
"But how do you go back to the other guy when this guy drilled a 60 yard to win the game and drilled the one opportunity he had?" Cignetti said.
Michael Niziolek is the Indiana beat reporter for The Bloomington Herald-Times. You can follow him on X @michaelniziolek.
Want more Hoosiers coverage? Sign up for IndyStar's Hoosiers newsletter. Listen to Mind Your Banners, our IU Athletics-centric podcast, on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Watch the latest on IndyStar TV: Hoosiers.
This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: Indiana special teams has struggled. Why Curt Cignetti switched kickers