CALGARY – Around here, when the subject-matter turns to Mark Carney, locals get a bit guarded.
“Hmm,” they’ll say. “Carney.”
In theory, Calgarians should be super-duper enthusiastic about Canada’s 24th Prime Minister, the Right Honourable Mark Joseph Carney. He was born out West, and educated in Alberta. He delivered the Edmonton Journal as a boy. He shoveled driveways for spending money. He went to a regular, suburban public high school. He loved the Oilers (not typically an asset in Calgary).
So, he’s a Westerner, born and bred. Even Stephen Harper, a saint around here, is an immigrant: he was born in the Great Satan, Toronto.
But, still. “Carney,” they’ll say, eyes narrowed. “Hmm.”
A Conservative MP, speaking anonymously because his party is in group therapy, grimaces.
“He’s a conservative, isn’t he?” says the MP. “He’s sure stolen a lot of our conservative ideas.”
Carney deep-sixed carbon tax
About that, there can be no debate: Carney is indeed a thief . He’s done it right out in the open, too, and gotten away with it.
Two minutes after he was selected Liberal leader, Carney deep-sixed the carbon tax , the issue that Pierre Poilievre believed was his and his alone, stamp out no erasing.
Defence: Carney said he’d meet, and beat, the Conservative defence spending promise. Like, now. Not a decade from now. (He did.)
Capital gains, slashed. Justin Trudeau’s capital gains tax inclusion rate increase, which was deeply insane, had been another key Poilievre issue. Carney absconded with it in broad daylight. Conservatives were agog, then apoplectic.
Pipelines were the same story: under Justin Trudeau, anti-energy lunatics like Stephen Guilbeault became cabinet ministers. In response, Tories suggested they would build pipelines everywhere, 24/7. Carney’s first major project? Surprise surprise: a long-awaited Pacific Link . Eat his carbon dust, Pierre.
Trust issues among Calgarians
So, Mark Carney: Westerner, Albertan, loves the Oilers, does everything a Conservative PM would do, and then some. Walks and talks and chews meat like a real conservative. So why the doubting, Thomas?
Asked that, a very successful Calgary businessman surveys the ceiling at the lovely retreat favoured by the city’s conservative elite, the Glencoe Club.
“I just don’t trust him,” he says, after a long pause. “He’s still a damned Liberal.”
Sure, yes, but: if an election were held today, that damn Liberal would win several seats in Alberta. Ditto Saskatchewan. Carney is really, really popular out West, it is pointed out. Even in places where Grits were once only kept alive by endangered species legislation.
Who would Calgarians want to replace Poilievre?
Tops of cowboy boots are examined, uncomfortable silence ensues. The Conservative conversation turns to the (for now) Conservative Leader.
There is general agreement that Pierre Poilievre is a Dead Man Walking if he loses the long-held Conservative seat in Brantford-Brant South on Dec. 7. So, if forced to walk the plank by his caucus – because his caucus incontrovertibly possesses the power to fire the leader, ask Erin O’Toole – who would Calgarians consider a suitable replacement?
Not Jason Kenney. While seen as a far-Right guy when he was Harper’s Minister of Everything, Kenney was driven out of the Alberta premier’s digs by Wildrose types because he was seen as too far to the Left, irony of ironies. Not happening, the Calgarians say.
Another former Harper minister, James Moore? He goes on TV and says Carney makes “fantastic choices.” Nope.
Yet another former Harperite, Lisa Raitt? Not bilingual, reportedly not interested.
- Minister Lena Diab ripped over Liberals' immigration plan: 'STOP TRYING TO GASLIGHT US'
- LILLEY: Mark Carney’s Stellantis fight risks more than Brampton assembly plant
- EDITORIAL: Carney should boost cadets, not cut them
Speaking of not-bilingual, what about Doug Ford? Ontario’s Premier clearly wants the job. But – apart from the fact that he is detested by Western Conservatives for sticking a shiv in Poilievre in public, apart from the fact he’s the most-unpopular premier in Canada, and apart from the fact that his much-circulated recent attempt to speak “French” sounded like a Rosedale bridal party on a weekend-long bender whilst trying to order poutine from a street vendor in Hull at 3 a.m. – well, apart from all that, the Calgarians don’t like Ford either.
So, what is a true-blue Calgarian Conservative to do? That Liberal, Mark Carney, is mowing our grass! What is to be done?
Here at the Glencoe Club, just off Elbow Drive, there’ll be lots of time to ponder that one. Mark Carney is going to be prime minister for a long, long time.
And in their candid, private moments, Calgarians know that, too.