There is no way to describe Ohio State’s 2026 season as anything other than a spectacular failure.
The Buckeyes entered the new campaign with one of the most expensive rosters and coaching staffs in the sport as the clear favorite in the Big Ten, one of the favorites to win the national title and the preseason No. 1 team in the country.
Instead, Ohio State is sitting here at 7-4 after being the first ranked program in 32 tries to lose a game to Nebraska.
Nobody has saved more head coaching jobs in college football this season than Ryan Day, who has now found ways to lose to Steve Sarkisian, Lincoln Riley, Dan Lanning and Matt Rhule — all in one calendar year! That, however, is a story for another day…
The topic at hand is the failed regime that has allowed Ohio State to reach this point.
It starts with roster building.
I wrote last week that Mark Pantoni deserves some of the blame for the Buckeyes’ disastrous 2026 season, which has now only gotten worse this weekend. That remains true, as he and Day are responsible for deciding which players they want to bring into the program, both via recruiting and the transfer portal.
When it comes to the latter, these last two transfer portal classes have been a complete calamity.
Ohio State has added 28 players to its roster via the transfer portal these last two offseasons, and virtually none of them have made a positive impact on the field. The Buckeyes have spent millions of dollars on guys like Beau Atkinson, Ethan Onianwa, Cam Calhoun and Phillip Daniels — just to name a few glaring failures of talent identification — and all they have done is make the roster actively worse.
This comes on the heels of an almost perfect 2024 transfer portal class, which included superstars like Caleb Downs, Quinshon Judkins and others. That was also, conveniently, the last transfer portal class before Ross Bjork took over as Athletic Director, which I’m sure is just a coincidence…
Since Bjork’s arrival, Ohio State has refused to go out and actually land that same level of actual NFL talent, whether via the transfer portal or traditional high school recruiting. We have watched big name after big name spurn the Buckeyes in favor of other programs, simply because the powers that be in Columbus were unwilling to spend a few extra dollars.
They brought in Bjork, a failed athletic director at Texas A&M, for his ability to fundraise, but instead he has cut corners. So you get players like Atkinson instead, who having reportedly been giving an NIL deal north of $1 million, has more personal fouls than impact plays in his two years with the program.
Even the talented players they do manage to land are wildly mishandled, which brings us to the next point: coaching.
This Ohio State roster is undeniably less talented than probably every other team that Ryan Day has had in his time at the helm. That is not an excuse for Day, as he is partially in charge of building said roster, but it is objectively true.
However, on top of a much lower ceiling, the Buckeyes have made things even tougher by refusing to play younger guys who are clearly better than the veterans ahead of them.
We have seen flash plays in very limited reps from a pair of freshmen in Legend Bey and Khary Wilder — two players at positions Ohio State has struggled at this season. They have shown an explosiveness at running back and defensive line, respectively, that really nobody else on the current roster has given them at any point this year.
Their reward? Riding the bench.
Neither of them can get on the field with any regularity. The coaching staff will claim they haven’t seen enough in practice to be able to ‘trust’ these guys on game day, but yet I have to watch Isaiah West fumble every week and incompetent defensive line play across the board with seemingly zero repercussions.
That same accountability that young guys like Bey and Wilder are held to is not applied to the veterans.
West can give the ball away three times in four weeks and still play over Bey. The defensive line can go four weeks without a sack and Wilder still can’t get any snaps. Payton Pierce can play some of the worst football you’ve ever seen and still play critical downs over a much better player in Riley Pettijohn.
The list goes on and on. What is the point of recruiting electric, talented players if you aren’t going to play them?
It is one of the many failures of this abysmal coaching staff, and with Ohio State’s season now effectively over —with still a chance they lose at home to a very bad Michigan team next weekend — massive changes need to be made.
It shouldstart with firing Bjork and Day, but neither of those are likely to happen.
In Day’s case, there has never been an easier time for Ohio State to move on. With Jeremiah Smith off to the NFL, there are really only a handful of players set to be on the roster for 2027 that you’d really care all that much about losing.
After transition to more of a ‘CEO’ role, Day was supposed to lead the charge on roster construction, coaching staff overview and in-game decision making. All three of those areas are now significantly worse than they were just a few years ago.
Day’s own standard he set as Ohio State’s head coach is to complete three key objectives each season: beat Michigan, win the Big Ten, and win the national title. If he isn’t able to pull of a miraculous victory in The Game, he will be 5-for-23 in actually achieving said goals.
Holding him to his own words, Day’s tenure has been a failure.
Now in his eighth year with the program, Day is 2-4 against Michigan, has not won the Big Ten since the fake 2020 season, and got gifted a national title with a generationally talented roster that basically bullied the coaching staff into a better game plan — which they have since abandoned.
Unfortunately, while it is abundantly clear that Ohio State should fire Ryan Day, they are ultimately not going to do it. Bjork is too inept to make an actual tough decision, and so the only thing we can hope for heading into 2027 is wide scale coaching staff changes.
And when I said wide scale, I mean each and every member of this current coaching staff needs to be let go. There are zero redeeming qualities among this group, and if Day is going to continue to get dragged down by his own shortcomings, he needs to get some actual adults in the room.
On offense, every single one of offensive coordinator Arthur Smith down to every assistant — offensive line coach Tyler Bowen, tight ends coach Keenan Bailey, quarterbacks coach Billy Fessler, running backs coach Carlos Locklyn, and wide receivers coach Cortez Hankton — should all be replaced.
Bailey, Bowen and Fessler are the biggest offenders, and I’ve already written ad nauseam about how none of them should have ever been hired at a place like Ohio State in the first place, but they are the clearest examples of guys who under no circumstances can be allowed back in the Woody ever again once this season comes to a merciful close.
Locklyn got lucky to have a pair of NFL players in his room in year one in Columbus, but the running back position has since fallen off a cliff, and all the guys in that unit have gotten worse under his tutelage. The same goes for Hankton, who despite recruiting some players with high pedigree, the wide receiver room is in a terrible place after Jeremiah Smith leaves.
The same can be said on defense, where Matt Patricia has stolen $3.75 million from the university after Bjork and his cronies rushed to bid against themselves for a guy we can now see was simply gifted one of the most talented Ohio State defenses ever. In hindsight, he actually underperformed with that group given what guys like Arvell Reese and Sonny Styles have done in the NFL this year.
Patricia obviously needs to be fired, but so too does every other member of the defensive coaching staff — defensive line coach Larry Johnson, cornerbacks coach Tim Walton, safeties coach Matt Guerrieri and even, unfortunately, linebackers coach James Laurinaitis.
Walton and Johnson are the most important firings.
Ohio State’s defensive line has gotten worse and worse year after year, basically since Chase Young left, and this 2026 group is the worst unit we have seen maybe in program history. It is high time for LJ to go and enjoy retirement, even with a pair of five-stars set to join the roster (this coaching staff wouldn’t play them next year anyway).
Walton has gotten a huge pass during his time with the Buckeyes, but this cornerbacks room is a nightmare. If Ohio State’s corners don’t arrive as basically finished products (Davison Igbinosun from the portal, Jay Timmons as a freshman, etc.) they receive zero development. Guys are routinely out of position, and nobody has any clue of how to play a ball in the air.
Ohio State’s corners have ZERO interceptions this season — not one! Look at a guy like Devin Sanchez, who came to Columbus as a five-star but looks lost out there more often than not. Even look at Jermaine Mathews, who once looked like he could be a star, only to get worse with more time under Walton.
Guerrieri can go too. Jaylen McClain looked like he was set to be the next great safety at Ohio State, but this season has been a massive disappointment from him. Behind him, there are seemingly no other guys at the position who are capable of playing football at this level.
Laurinaitis is a tough one. You’d love to latch on to a program legend, especially after Styles’ and Reese’s 2025 season, but how much of that was coaching and how much of that was just pure talent?
Ohio State’s linebackers this season, outside of Pettijohn, have been awful. Payton Pierce makes Tuf Borland look like Ryan Shazier, and to continue to give him significant snaps every week over guys like Pettijohn, TJ Alford and even Cincere Johnson is a huge red flag. That group as a whole has also been largely out of position more often than not, which is a coaching issue.
Again, there are no redeemable coaches on this staff, including the guy in charge. However, if you aren’t going to rip the bandaid now and you’re choosing to enter the 2027 season with a lame duck head coach, the best you can hope for is to tear this thing down to the studs.
Should we trust Ryan Day and Ross Bjork to make these hires? Absolutely not!
Both guys have a track record of complete and utter failure when it comes to hiring decisions of any kind — see Bjork’s decision to hire Jake Diebler to coach the men’s basketball team and Day’s decision to hire… well, his entire current staff.
There is little to be gained from any changes at Ohio State unless it starts at the top. Everything else just feels like lipstick on a pig. Right now, unfortunately that seems like the only reasonable option.
If nothing else, Day needs to go away from the NFL-ification of this Ohio State program and get back to hiring quality, experienced college assistants. That would at least be a step in the right direction if they have any hope of regaining some relevancy in 2027.